FAIR USE NOTICE

FAIR USE NOTICE

A BEAR MARKET ECONOMICS BLOG


This site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in an effort to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. we believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml

If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond ‘fair use’, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

FAIR USE NOTICE FAIR USE NOTICE: This page may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. This website distributes this material without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for scientific, research and educational purposes. We believe this constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in 17 U.S.C § 107.

Read more at: http://www.etupdates.com/fair-use-notice/#.UpzWQRL3l5M | ET. Updates
FAIR USE NOTICE FAIR USE NOTICE: This page may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. This website distributes this material without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for scientific, research and educational purposes. We believe this constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in 17 U.S.C § 107.

Read more at: http://www.etupdates.com/fair-use-notice/#.UpzWQRL3l5M | ET. Updates

All Blogs licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

How the Hell Do You Get Out of Debt If You're Not a CEO Raking in Millions?


AlterNet.org




How the Hell Do You Get Out of Debt If You're Not a CEO Raking in Millions?


Americans want to get out of debt, but the working majority are tapped out and having real problems making ends meet.

Americans are doing everything they can to pay down their debts, but with prices rising and wages stagnating, they just can't dig themselves out of the red.

“Since early 2010 we’ve been seeing a consistent focus on cutting debt as part of an overall strategy to improve family finances and embrace frugal living,” said Scott Spiker, CEO of First Command Financial Services, Inc. According to a monthly survey of consumer attitudes conducted by his firm, "Eight out of 10 respondents said that paying down debt is currently their No. 1 priority.”

They're working hard – and sacrificing – to make that happen. According to the survey of 1,000 middle-class households, more than half or respondents say they're cutting back on everyday expenses, four out of 10 say they're “using all of their extra income” to pay down debt and 15 percent are even taking second jobs or working extra shifts to dig themselves out of the hole.

As the shock of the financial crash took hold, these efforts looked like they were paying off. According to Federal Reserve Data, American households lopped 4 percent off of their consumer debts in 2009. They kept it up through the first three quarters of 2010 – paying down consumer debt to the tune of about 3 more percent.

But since then, the pattern has reversed itself – from last fall until today, households are again running up the credit cards, taking out lines of credit and sinking deeper into the red. According to the First Command surveys, while over two-thirds of respondents said they are at least “somewhat aggressively” working to pay down debt, more than four in 10 have taken out at least one loan in the previous 11 months. Almost one in five got a new credit card; 14 percent took out a car loan and 11 percent said they'd grabbed a retailers debit card. According to the researchers, “new debt trend appears to be accelerating, too. During the previous three months, nine percent of survey respondents took on new credit card debt and five percent took out an auto loan.”

What's going on is not difficult to discern. Incomes are flat, and Americans' disposable income has actually declined this year after adjusting for inflation. At the same time, prices have been ticking up, slowly but sure, led by a big run-up in gas prices (which just began retreating somewhat in the past months).

For a while, debt was also falling because the banks were tightening up their lending standards. It appears to be that people are paying off one debt and then just as soon taking on another to make ends meet. Americans are tapped out, and despite their expressed desire to get out of debt, they just can't get off the treadmill.

The backdrop to all of this is the long-term upward redistribution of wealth in this country, with those on top of the pile taking an ever increasing share of the national income and leaving the rest of us to fight over the crumbs. As the Financial Times notes, “Starting in 1975, male US median pay has stagnated in real terms, while gross domestic product continued to rise rapidly.”

Growth in per capita national income must go somewhere. In the US, the money flowed almost exclusively to the very richest. The earnings of US individuals with pre-tax income in the top 1 percent accounted for 8 percent of total in 1974, but rocketed to 18 percent by 2008, according to the world top incomes database, a resource compiled from tax return data. Even larger proportionate rises in the share of income went to the top 1 percent of those with incomes within the 1 top percent.

When that trend started, household debt represented about 45 percent of our economic output. By 2006, it had reached 100 percent. In the mid-1970s, we managed to put away about 10 percent of what we earned for a rainy day; by the time the crash hit in 2008, our savings rate was close to zero – we were spending money even though our incomes weren't rising, and we pulled that feat off by running up piles of debt rather than squirreling away a few acorns for when we might need it.

And it's important to understand that it is this overhang of personal debt, rather than the public debt over which Washington is obsessing, that is really dragging down the economy. It's an economy that's built largely on consumer spending after all, and American consumers don't have any spare cash to spend; real personal consumption was relatively flat at the beginning of the year, but has declined over the past two months.

Although income inequality has been on the rise in many countries in recent years, nowhere has the trend been longer or more severe than in the United States. With middle-class wages continuing to rise, the citizens of many developed countries were able to continue to save money and this left them in far better shape when the crash hit. Consider a few wealthy countries' savings rates alongside our own (courtesy of Seeking Alpha), and note how far behind we were as the 1990s got underway:

savings

All of this tells us that growing inequality isn't just a moral issue or a matter of people being “envious” of the rich, as many within our elites would have you believe, but is a severe drag on economic growth. As economist Jared Bernstein, considering why Sweden has fared better than we have since the crash, put it, “When most of the growth ends up in the top few percentiles of the income or wealth scale, Nordstrom does well at one end of the barbell economy and Walmart prospers at the other end. But there’s a gap in consumption, investment and demand in general in the broad middle. And this dynamic could make it tougher for a recovery to take hold among the broad American middle class.”

Sunday, June 26, 2011

Injustice In America: A Tale Of Two Crimes

CommonDreams.org


Consider Paul Allen, 55, a former mortgage CEO who defrauded lenders of over $3 billion. This week, prosecutors celebrated the fact they got him a 40-month prison sentence. Consider Roy Brown, 54, a hungry homeless man who robbed a Louisiana bank of $100 - the teller gave him more but he handed the rest back. He felt bad the next day and surrendered to police. He got 15 years. Justice in America has a ways to go.

Saturday, June 25, 2011

Shaping Up the 21st Century

ZBOLGS

Shaping Up the 21st Century

By Bob Simpson at Jun 24, 2011


Internship


On the docks of the USA it was called “the shape up”. Each morning hundreds of desperate men would assemble to compete for a day’s work unloading ships. Whoever would work for less or gave the biggest kickbacks to the port bosses was hired. The rest were sent away. It was a system rife with corruption, bribery & favoritism. Every day was a race to the bottom. Watch Marlon Brando in “On the Waterfront” to get an idea of how bad it was.

The worst abuses of “the shape up” ended when longshore unions forced a series of reforms from the reluctant port bosses. It was a long bloody struggle as typified by the 1934 San Francisco General Strike; but longshore workers won a modicum of dignity and could carve out a better life for themselves and their families.

But now in our Brave New Economy, “the shape up” is back, but in a 21st century form. This time it is not just blue collar guys in cloth caps fighting one another for a day’s pittance. It’s college students and graduates competing not even for a pittance, but for the right to work for nothing. They assemble at job fairs and college recruiting days, armed with little more than their resumes, their thrift store business attire, their frozen smiles and their heads full of anxiety.

They are the interns. Facing a dismal economy, a mountain of debt and a society enamored with Social Darwinism, their struggle for survival in a harsh environment is hardly noticed by most of us. In his new book Intern Nation, Ross Perlin concludes that most free internships are probably in violation of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938. But of course authorities here in the USA pursue parking tickets with much greater zeal than they do labor law violations.

Corporate scofflaws are well aware of this and thus see gold in those piles of resumes.

“People who work for free are far hungrier than anybody who has a salary, so they’re going to outperform, they’re going to try to please, they’re going to be creative,” says Kelly Fallis, chief executive of Remote Stylist, a Toronto and New York-based startup that provides Web-based interior design services. “From a cost savings perspective, to get something off the ground, it’s huge. Especially if you’re a small business.”

Yes indeedy, Ms Fallis, hunger and desperation are motivating forces. But if they are such great motivators, why do CEO’s of companies both big and small seek to be so well fed and comfortable? Why do corporations throw such huge salaries at their leaders to “get the best people”, when according to analysts like Ms. Fallis, it’s the hungry and desperate who outperform and are the most creative?

This kind of public hypocrisy is the coin of the realm. Our Brave New Economy demands it from its leaders. If you can live comfortably with lies, you too may yet gain entry to the halls of power. Of course there are only so many halls of power and only so many job openings for kings and queens.

What about the rest of us? The proliferation of free internships is only part of a longterm trend in the global economy. Economists call it the “informal” economy. The informal economy used to mean paying nannies, landscape workers and home repair experts cash under the table. It also referred to criminal activites like fencing stolen goods and black marketeering.

According to John Russo of the Center for Working Class Studies, the formal economy is being informalized.

“Increasingly, the conditions of the informal economy are being experienced in the formal economy, though they are generally ignored or hidden by such glossy terms as consulting, internships, subcontracting, and privatization.”

Look at it that way and you can see that free internships are an excellent way to prepare for a working life with no security, no retirement, no longterm co-worker relationships, no paid vacations, no paid sick leave or any other once common amenities.

The traditional working class solidarity of getting to know your co-workers over time and knowing who will join common struggles to fight oppression and exploitation will no longer exist.

Instead, you will be part of a global “shape up”, a war of all against all, as each individual fighting for a temporary job prepares to stab the person next to them in the back (hopefully metaphorically, but you never know).

Or maybe not. If this is the New Normal according to the pundits, there is a New Abnormal that is being ignored in the corporate-owned media. The New Abnormal is the rebellion against the New Normal.

According to John Russo of the Center for Working Class Studies:

“A number of labor and social justice organizations have formed the Excluded Workers Congress with goal of organizing workers in the informal economy, connecting them with grassroots movements, and developing strategic responses to informalization. They aim to challenge discrimination in the current labor market, build support for ongoing campaigns to improve working conditions, expand labor rights for excluded workers, and advocate for policies that support all workers’ right to organize.”

Blue collar workers in the informal economy have been fighting back for a long time. Across the nation there are workers’ centers that bring immigrant workers together for job training, legal counseling and strategizing how to improve their working conditions.

The Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) has been organizing food service workers at places like Starbucks and Jimmy John’s Sandwiches where turnover is high and the pay is low.

Graduate students across the nation have organized unions to fight back against colleges and universities who see them as disposable and easily replaced cheap labor.

Within today’s unions are examples of workers in communications, media and construction who may work on a number of different projects over the course of a year, but who enjoy at least some protections.

The message is,”You are not alone.”

Let’s face it though, these efforts and others affect only a small number of people. With more workers being drawn into “the shape up”, we face a situation with no easy answers and lots of difficult questions. Modern devices like mobile phones and laptops make communication possible among people who can not talk face to face on a daily basis. That’s great, but do we even know what to say to one another through Facebook, Twitter and SMS?

Our colleges and universities are being corporatized and privatized. The mass media is largely off limits to us. Long work hours and exhausting days searching for new projects and short term employment leave little time for anything else.

But against these obstacles, we still have to make time for some deep thinking about the challenges that face us. Unless of course we want a lifetime in “the shape up”, losing all hope and humanity.

Reflections on the U.S. Counterrevolution



Reflections on the U.S. Counterrevolution




We are in the midst of a counterrevolution and intensifying class war. What makes its present efflorescence so striking is that it is taking place under the presidency of Barack Obama, a man elected in good measure by an aroused mass base that is now taking its lumps. The power structure no longer permits serious attention to the welfare of that mass base. The great upward redistribution of income, the increased importance of money in elections, the centralization of corporate and media control and the media's rightward drift, globalization, outsourcing, the weakening of organized labor, and the permanent war system, have all combined to effectively eliminate a "populist" option in politics. The Democrats invariably betray their voting base, but not their investor base.

This is dramatically evident in polls, which regularly show that the majority doesn't approve of the serial wars in which the leadership's engage (including the attack on Libya), would prefer more infrastructure and educational expenditures and smaller "defense" outlays, are more worried about jobs than the deficit, and do not favor slashing Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security. The mainstream media, as part of the elite, play down or misrepresent these poll results, which occur despite a propaganda barrage by this same media that supports the permanent war system and other essential ingredients of the counterrevolution. The media certainly do not allow the poll-expressed preferences to influence their news coverage, by, for example, featuring more heavily the politics of procurement, military waste, or the relative administrative costs of Medicare and private medical insurance. "National security" outlays are normalized, discussions of tradeoffs minimized. Years ago the New York Times had annual op-ed columns which would graphically describe what the tax dollars for a new fleet of bombers, fighters, helicopter gunships, or another atomic submarine or aircraft carrier would buy in schools, teachers, bridges, and roads. But that was apparently too revealing and was long since discontinued and never replaced.

It is also of interest to see how closely the threat of "deficits" is correlated with the threat of "populism," i.e., a concern for the well-being of ordinary citizens. This deficit threat quickly leaps to prominence when a Democrat assumes the presidency, however modest that populist threat might really be. Carter, Clinton, and now Obama have found outcries of menacing fiscal deficits and national bankruptcy ever present during their terms of office, while a Reagan or George W. Bush can greatly enlarge the deficit and national debt with only modest expressions of concern by important people, and with no Tea Parties organized to urge fiscal sanity (among other matters). The mainstream media do not discuss or explain this differential treatment—it just happens, with their close cooperation. In fact, the media give the Tea Party very disproportionate as well as uncritical attention, whether out of sympathy or fear of being tagged "liberal media" (very often both).

Entitlement

Word usage more generally accommodates to counterrevolutionary and class warfare demands. The key word "entitlement" has come to mean claims of ordinary citizens and "special interests" (usually some segment of the general population like unions or the aged), with the implication that these claims are somehow undeserved, or excessive, and involve favoritism toward the old at the expense of the young. The wealthy and the leaders of the military-industrial complex do not get their tax breaks, subsidies, and contracts as "entitlements," nor do they get "handouts" or "doles." They get taxpayer dollars as incentives and rewards for services rendered and/or possible productive flows and trickles-down to the lesser citizens. Military budgets are, of course, for "national security."The link between "entitlements" and "populism" is clear—both involve benefits to the majority and are in consequence targets in counterrevolution and class warfare.

"Moderates" and "centrists" see the light and are prepared to chop away at these entitlements, while protecting elite claims against those who seem bent on a "class war," or who are insensitive to our "national security" needs that continue to enlarge on all continents and bodies of water (including the Baltic and Black Seas). The mainstream media love moderates and centrists so these are "purr" words, as opposed to "snarl" words like entitlements and populism. It is a notable and humorous fact that the media regularly admonish the Democrats to move to the center whenever the latter suffer election setbacks. The Democrats may have already done so with a vengeance and lost heavily and polls may show the public preferring populist policies and peace and reduced arms, but the corporate community and media editors don't prefer them so "Get thee to the center."

The centrists and moderates in and out of the media regard Paul Ryan's budget plan as "serious" and "courageous." The centrist-moderates also show themselves to be serious and courageous in treating the Ryan plan with an open mind when it seems that public awareness of its content causes strong negative reactions. Politicians who are prepared (or eager) to push their country into a foreign war are regularly described as courageous, even more so when the polls and unusually large marching crowds indicate that their voting constituency is opposed to the war. Bill Clinton was described as courageous in spending much of his political capital in getting the North American Free Trade Agreement passed into law in 1993, when his Democratic voting constituency and Democratic legislators clearly opposed it and only the corporate community (and mainstream media) favored it. Here again there is a nice correlation between establishment designation with a purr word (courage) and adherence to a corporate-mainstream media party line—getting us into a war; anti-populist and pro-corporate "reforms."

Ryan v. the People

The anti-populist, pro-counterrevolution and class war bias of the media has been clearly displayed in their comparative treatments of the Paul Ryan budget plan and the People's Budget offered on April 6 by congresspeople Keith Ellison and Raul Grijalva, co-chairs of the 80-member Congressional Progressive Caucus. Amusingly, the economist Jeffrey Sachs wrote a piece in the Huffington Post on April 8 in which he calls the Ryan plan "far right" and an "absurdly vicious attack on the poor and working class," whereas the People's Budget is "centrist," as on point after point it advocates what polls show to be majority demands and reflects "the true values of the American people" ("The People's Budget: What a 'Centrist' Budget Should Look Like").

Years ago Jeffrey Sachs was famous and popular with the mainstream media as an adviser to various governments (Poland, Bolivia, Russia) and the IMF, as well as an advocate of "structural adjustment" policies. In fact, in 1996, I referred to him as the "neoliberal world's leading shock therapist" ("War Criminals [Economics Division]: The Dirty Twenty," Z Magazine, November 1996). But Sachs subsequently changed into a populist, becoming badly out of step with the establishment moderates and centrists. He is now marginalized with his fellow immoderates and extremists to the left of Barack Obama, who speak for a People's Budget or something even more absurd. Sachs's current budgetary views were mentioned recently in the media only by Dana Milbank in the Washington Post, who notes Sach's claim that the People's Budget is "centrist" and that Obama's is "right of center." This serves Milbank only as a joke and as the basis for a putdown on the impracticality of these extremists, with nary a mention of what the public might want on these matters ("If Progressives Ran the World," WP, April 14, 2011).

Apart from Milbank, the Washington Post ignored the People's Budget and the New York Times never even mentioned it as a news item. There was, however, a column by Paul Krugman in the New York Times that did give the People's Budget a strong pat on the back ("Let's Take a Hike," April 24, 2011), but that column stood alone. On the other hand, Paul Ryan's budget plan got massive mainstream media attention and, as noted, in the familiar routine, he was found to be "courageous" (Brooks, Zakaria) and his proposals that Sachs found "absurdly vicious" were "serious" and worthy of attention (see Fair's Media Advisory: "Mr. Serious: the Ryan budget plan and the beltway media," April 14, 2011). Of course, Ryan's budget was put forward by the Republican head of the House Budget Committee and was passed in the House, but it is far from enactment into law and its extremism and huge distance from public interests and preferences makes it even more urgent that it be compared with alternatives like the People's Budget. That is surely what a democratic media would do, but we don't have one.

The party line which the mainstream media have internalized, that contributes to the counterrevolutionary process and rules out serious attention to the People's Budget, is displayed in Milbank's piece and Richard W. Stevenson's news article discussion of the budget issues in the New York Times ("The Budget Debate, Revealed," April 17, 2011). For Milbank, the authors of the People's Budget are "starry-eyed progressives," not serious or courageous. Stevenson never mentions the People's Budget.

Stevenson also never mentions the Pentagon/national security budget, while Milbank is amused at the audacity and unrealism of the authors of the People's Budget who want to end the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and substantially reduce the size of U.S. military forces—as does the obviously "irrelevant" underlying population. Milbank is horrified at the thought that the "weapons programs would go begging." Stevenson tells us that the real issue posed by the Ryan budget and Tea-Party-moment Republicans is the size of the government—Ryan's, he says, is "a manifesto for limited government." But Stevenson and the established ideology don't include the Pentagon/National Security complex in something called "government," which obscures the fact that it is more the composition of government than its total size that is at stake.

Stevenson says that it is the aging of the baby boomers and "costs of maintaining Medicare and Social Security [that] have put the two pillars of the social welfare system on the table for re-examination." He never allows the possibility that they are back on the table by choice of the dominant power interests, which also causes the military budget and tax increases for the elite and corporations not to be on the table. The former are "entitlements," hence eligible; the latter are elite-approved, hence out of Stevenson's sight. He fails to mention that the Ryan plan does nothing to impede rising medical costs, but does eventually shift medical costs from the government and insurance companies to aging medical users, which is why Dean Baker contends that the Ryan plan is basically not hostile to big government but is about shifting costs and benefits ("The Battle Is Over Money, Not Philosophy," Truthout, April 14, 2011).

Stevenson bypasses the jobs issue, in accord with the establishment consensus—he tells us that the tepid nature of the recovery "following big stimulus packages" has called into question "Keynesianism as the default policy option for government." But, even at the time they were enacted, critics like Baker and Krugman were calling the stimulus packages clearly inadequate. The "markets" and "deregulation" failed even more clearly, as did the Bush tax cuts, but Stevenson doesn't mention these as flawed default options or allow a debate on these issues.

On tax increases, Stevenson quotes William Galston (a former Clinton administration official, now at Brookings, who is to Stevenson's "left") that the Democrats "can no longer say with a straight face that raising taxes on the wealthy is going to enable them to pay over the next generation for the programs they cherish." But can anybody say with a straight face that they couldn't contribute a great deal? And increased corporate taxes and closing tax loopholes? And who has claimed that relying on them alone would solve all problems? That exhausts Stevenson's "debate" on taxes.

The mainstream media follow the party line adhered to by Milbank and Stevenson, with the entitlements of the majority subjected to biased debate and attack, elite privileges kept out of range and confined to "unserious" People's Budgets. There are exceptions, like Paul Krugman, but they are rare. Interestingly, in his useful "The Intimidated Fed" (April 30, 2011), Krugman points out that, although inflation is low and is predicted by Fed analysts to stay low, whereas unemployment is high and expected to come down painfully slowly, Fed Chair Ben Bernanke has no plan for further action to reduce unemployment. Krugman explains this as a result of intimidation by inflation-mongers who keep seeing runaway inflation as imminent. He doesn't mention that this policy, and the high unemployment and weak economy associated with it, are helpful in maintaining a sizable reserve army of unemployed labor, keeping pressure on government budgets, and making the attack on public unions and public services more plausible. They are instruments of the counterrevolution and class warfare.

Z


Edward S. Herman is an economist, media critic, and author of numerous articles and books. His latest is The Politics of Genocide (with David Peterson).

Friday, June 24, 2011

Between Rock Bottom and a Hard Place



Between Rock Bottom and a Hard Place

As the recovery falters, state and federal governments are reducing benefits for the unemployed.

| | web only

Last week, the housing market took another dive. Unemployment remained at about 9 percent, where it’s hovered since January, and the economy added just 54,000 jobs—far fewer than expected. The private sector added 83,000 new jobs, but continued government layoffs pushed the net number down.

Between Rock Bottom and a Hard Place
(Flickr/aflcio)

But you won’t hear much about the housing and hiring crisis from politicians in Washington and in statehouses across the country, which remain focused on cutting deficits rather than addressing—or even mentioning—these problems. They are cutting programs meant to jump-start the economy as well as programs on which struggling people depend: unemployment benefits, welfare benefits, retraining funds, and child-care subsidies. This will leave American workers across the country stranded and could hamper the faltering recovery.

Cuts to unemployment benefits

Unemployment benefits are on the chopping block, at both the state and federal levels. They’re certainly not cheap: With 14 million people officially unemployed as of May, the price tag for unemployment benefits is projected at $129 billion for 2011, according to a report from the Pew Fiscal Analysis Initiative. Since the recession, benefits have been extended to a maximum of 99 weeks, thanks to both federal and state add-ons.

Now, as the Huffingon Post’s Arthur Delaney has extensively tracked, many states are cutting back. Michigan, Missouri, and Arkansas have shrunk the number of weeks people can receive state aid. A similar bill in Florida awaits the governor’s signature, and more states are likely to follow. And the federal bills creating the 99 weeks max all expire at the end of 2011, so people still unemployed come January will be abruptly bumped down to their state limits.

“If we withdraw these unemployment benefits that families need and rely on and that are pumped back into local economies, that might do more harm than good,” says Christine Owens, executive director of the National Employment Law Project. For every dollar spent on unemployment benefits, two dollars in economic growth are generated, Owens says, citing Department of Labor research. The cuts are “likely to have a negative impact on the economic recovery, not to mention the impact on the families that are losing the support they need.”

Retraining programs

Government spending can also help people get hired for the jobs that are available—some 3.1 million as of March. Employers consistently complain that there’s a mismatch between workers’ training and the jobs on offer, says Rachel Gragg, federal policy director at the National Skills Coalition, which advocates for job training. Job training can help people move from one industry or another and also help the long-term unemployed regain any skills they’ve lost.

But Congress cut more than $1 billion from job training in the current budget, leaving the assortment of programs with about $6.5 billion in funding. The original budget passed by the House had more than $4 billion in cuts, and Gragg expects to see similarly deep cuts proposed for fiscal 2012. “If the assumption is that as part of an economic recovery, we’re going to bring jobs back on line, we need to make sure people have the skills for those jobs,” she says.

Retraining is also the idea behind the Trade Adjustment Act, which provides training support for people who lose their jobs to international trade. But the TAA too has turned into a budget battleground. Since the program’s inception in 1974, it has exclusively served workers in “article producing” industries—people who make objects. The stimulus act made retraining available to people in the service sector for the first time: workers in call centers, back-office support, computer programmers. It also expanded the program to people who lose jobs to China and India, not just countries where the U.S. has a trade deal. Tens of thousands of newly eligible workers applied for aid. That expansion ended in February, with legislators saying it’s too costly to continue. The administration is battling this one out with Congress, holding up pending trade agreements with Korea and Colombia unless the expanded training gets reinstated.

Shrinking assistance to families

People who can’t find work, with or without training, and who exhaust unemployment benefits will find that the programs formerly known as welfare are shrinking as well. The total funding for the federal Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF) program was $16.8 billion in 2011, a drop of almost 15 percent from the two prior years. Four states and D.C. have cut monthly TANF benefits, says LaDonna Pavetti, an expert on family support programs with the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. The benefits aren’t huge to begin with; states give a median of $400 a month for a family of three, she says, and some give far less. TANF is “a weak safety net getting weaker,” Pavetti says.

Parents who are lucky enough to find work won’t be as able to depend on government child-care programs, either. The stimulus act added $1 billion for child-care assistance to the $12 billion provided by TANF and the Child Care and Development Block Grant; just $100 million of the boost made it into the new federal budget. In response, states have cut the number of children receiving care and the reimbursements to child-care providers. Waiting lists have exploded. The impact is immediate, says Helen Blank, an expert on child-care with the National Women’s Law Center. “Low-income parents are just one unstable child-care arrangement away from losing their job or having to drop out of school,” Blank says. And the cuts ripple out beyond the family. When parents can’t pay for care, child-care providers lose their jobs.

That’s not all. Because of the funding cuts, states are reducing other supports such as the earned income tax credit, subsidized jobs programs, and small lump sums for things like back-to-school clothes, Pavetti adds. States are also tightening lifetime limits on benefits, dropping the maximum number of weeks people can get cash assistance. “We are expecting by the end of this we will see more cuts,” she says. The House committee responsible for child-care allocation is taking 2004 spending levels as a starting point for its fiscal 2012 budget, Blank adds.

With a projected deficit of $1.5 trillion in 2011, these cuts might seem inevitable. But this isn’t just an issue of balancing a ledger, because America has wealth to draw on. Corporate profits are 20 percent higher than they were before the recession. And per-capita income is growing steadily, too: It’s projected to grow more than 60 percent over the next three decades, just about as much as it did over the last 30 years. If corporations are clearing double-digit profits and incomes are on the rise, why is the federal government so broke? “There’s no fundamental economic issue here,” says Lawrence Mishel, president of the Economic Policy Institute. “It’s just a matter of politics and policies that are making government less able to provide.”


Thursday, June 23, 2011

Patriot Act Eroding Civil Liberties

AlterNet.org


The Constitutional “precedent” set by the Patriot Act appears to be serving to accelerate the rapid disintegration of civil liberties in this country.


With the stroke of an autopen, the once articulate critic of the Patriot Act signed a four year extension of the most dangerous assault on American civil liberties in US history without a single additional privacy protection.

One would think that this reauthorization would have incited vigorous debate in the halls of Congress and at least a fraction of the breathless 24/7 media coverage allotted the Anthony Weiner “sexting” scandal. Instead, three weeks ago the House (250 to 153) and Senate (72 to 23) approved, and the President signed, an extension of this landmark attack on the Bill of Rights with little notice and even less debate.

Most disturbing was the extension – without modification – of the Act’s three most controversial provisions:

• allows broad warrants to be issued by a secretive court for any type of record, from financial to medical, without the government having to declare that the information sought is connected to a terrorism or espionage investigation;
• allows the FBI to obtain wiretaps from the secret court (i.e. “roving wiretaps”,) known as the FISA court, without identifying the target or what method of communication is to be tapped;
• allows the FISA court warrants for the electronic monitoring of a person (“lone wolf” measure ) for whatever reason — even without showing that the suspect is an agent of a foreign power or a terrorist.

Also in need of reform, are what's called National Security Letters (NSLs) – which allow the FBI, without a court order, to obtain telecommunication, financial and credit records deemed “relevant” to a government investigation. The FBI issues about 50,000 a year and an internal watchdog has repeatedly found the flagrant misuse of this power.

The Long Record of Patriot Act Abuses

Any meaningful debate over whether to reauthorize any and all of these provisions without significant additional privacy protections should include a few key questions. One, have these provisions made us significantly safer (i.e. are there documented incidences they have led to capturing terrorists plotting against us?)? Two, is there any evidence that they have been abused? Three, is their claimed usefulness somehow jeopardized by the kinds of modest reforms privacy rights groups (and others) advocate? And finally, have we created a dangerous constitutional precedent?

Thanks to the relentless work by groups like the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) - and information uncovered by the Freedom of Information Act - there is little to no evidence that these provisions, as written, have made us any safer. Yet there’s a long list of incidences of unadulterated government abuse and malpractice for a host of purposes other than fighting terrorism. In other words, the threat this Act, and these particular provisions pose to the basic Constitutional rights of American citizens is not hypothetical, but documented fact.

Consider what we know:

• The FBI admitted in a recent report to the President’s Intelligence Oversight Board that it violated the law at least 800 times on national security letters, going well beyond even the loose safeguards in the original provision. According to the report the FBI “may have violated the law or government policy as many as 3,000 times” between 2003 and 2007, according to the Justice Department Inspector General, while collecting bank, phone and credit card records using NSLs.
• As Adam Sewer of the American Prospect notes: "It's no secret that the FBI's use of NSLs - a surveillance tool that allows the FBI to gather reams of information on Americans from third-party entities (like your bank) without a warrant or without suspecting you of a crime - have resulted in widespread abuses. All that the FBI needs to demand your private information from a third-party entity is an assertion that such information is "relevant" to a national security investigation -- and the NSLs come with an accompanying gag order that's almost impossible to challenge in court.”
• NSLs were used by the Bush administration after the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks to demand that libraries turn over the names of books that people had checked out. In fact, there were at least 545 libraries that received such demands in the year following passage of the Patriot Act alone.
• The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) uncovered "indications that the FBI may have committed upwards of 40,000 possible intelligence violations in the 9 years since 9/11." It said it could find no records of whether anyone was disciplined for the infractions.
• Under the Bush Administration, the FBI used the Patriot Act to target liberal groups, particularly anti-war, environment, and anti-globalization, during the years between 2001 and 2006 in particular.
• According to a recent report by the ACLU, there have been 111 incidents of illegal domestic political surveillance since 9/11 in 33 states and the District of Columbia. The report shows that law enforcement and federal officials work closely to monitor the political activity of individuals deemed suspicious, an activity common during the Cold War – including protests, religious activities and other rights protected by the first amendment. The report also noted how the FBI monitors peaceful protest groups and in some cases attempted to prevent protest activities.
• According to a July 2009 report from the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, only three of the 763 "sneak-and-peek" requests in fiscal year 2008 involved terrorism cases. Sixty-five percent were drug related.

John Whitehead, author of "Renewing the Patriot Act While America Sleeps", described our post Patriot Act reality in appropriately stark terms, writing, “"Suddenly, for the first time in American history, federal agents and police officers were authorized to conduct black bag “sneak-and-peak” searches of homes and offices and confiscate your personal property without first notifying you of their intent or their presence. The law also granted the FBI the right to come to your place of employment, demand your personal records and question your supervisors and fellow employees, all without notifying you; allowed the government access to your medical records, school records and practically every personal record about you; and allowed the government to secretly demand to see records of books or magazines you’ve checked out in any public library and Internet sites you’ve visited.”

And now - according to the New York Times - new guidelines from the Justice Department will allow FBI agents to investigate people and organizations "proactively" without firm evidence for suspecting criminal activity. The new rules will free up agents to infiltrate organizations, search household trash, use surveillance teams, search databases, and conduct lie detector tests, even without suspicion of any wrongdoing.

In other words, the Constitutional “precedent” set by the Patriot Act appears to be serving to accelerate the rapid disintegration of civil liberties in this country.

Of equal concern is what we still don’t know about how the government might be using the Act, highlighted by recent statements made by US Senators regarding what they termed “secret Patriot Act provisions”. Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR), an outspoken critic of the recent reauthorization, stated, "When the American people find out how their government has secretly interpreted the Patriot Act they will be stunned and they will be angry." As a member of the Senate Intelligence Committee Wyden is in a position to know, as he receives classified briefings from the executive branch.

In recent years, three other current and former members of the US Senate - Mark Udall (D-CO), Dick Durbin (D-IL), and Russ Feingold (D-WI) - have provided similar warnings. We can't be sure what these senators are referring to, but the evidence suggests, and some assert, that the current administration is using Section 215 of the Patriot Act - a provision that gives the government access to "business records" - as the legal basis for the large-scale collection of cell phone location records.

The fact that in 2009 Sprint disclosed that law enforcement made 8 million requests in 2008 alone for its customer’s cell phone GPS data for purposes of locational tracking should only add to these legitimate privacy concerns.

Security Versus Privacy: A False Dichotomy


The Patriot Act was sold as an indispensable weapon in the government’s arsenal to fight and “win” the “War on Terror”. We were assured that the sole purpose of these unprecedented powers granted government were to locate and catch terrorists - not raid the homes of pot dealers and wiretap peace activists. Monitoring political groups and activities deemed “threatening” (i.e. environmentalists, peace activists), expanding the already disastrous and wasteful war on drugs, and eavesdropping on journalists isn’t about fighting terrorism, it’s about stifling dissent and consolidating power – at the expense of civil liberties.

How ironic that the very “tool” hailed as our nation’s protector has instead been used to violate the very Constitutional protections we are allegedly defending from “attack” by outside threats. What was promised as a “temporary”, targeted law to keep us safe from terror has morphed into a rewriting of the Bill of Rights.

John Whitehead explains: “The Patriot Act drove a stake through the heart of the Bill of Rights, violating at least six of the ten original amendments–the First, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Seventh and Eighth Amendments–and possibly the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments, as well. The Patriot Act also redefined terrorism so broadly that many non-terrorist political activities such as protest marches, demonstrations and civil disobedience were considered potential terrorist acts, thereby rendering anyone desiring to engage in protected First Amendment expressive activities as suspects of the surveillance state.”

It’s almost as if Benjamin Franklin had the Patriot Act in mind when he famously stated, "Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."

Noted privacy and security expert Bruce Schneier expanded on this false dichotomy, writing, “…those who would give up privacy for security are likely to end up with neither,” concluding "If you set up the false dichotomy, of course people will choose security over privacy -- especially if you scare them first. But it's still a false dichotomy. There is no security without privacy.”

The fact that the odds of EVER being killed or maimed in a terrorist attack are a fraction of that posed by being hit by lightning, we should always approach government demands for increasingly intrusive and ripe for abuse authority with a healthy dose of skepticism and a large grain of salt.

The long, documented record of government overreach and abuse since 9/11 begs a larger question, “Can we truly defeat “the terrorists” by succumbing to fear and embracing a less free and more authoritarian society (which are ostensibly primary goals of terrorists)?”

Constitutional scholar Glenn Greenwald further illuminates this false “security versus privacy” dichotomy promulgated by those with inherent conflicts of interest, writing:

“The problem is never that the U.S. Government lacks sufficient power to engage in surveillance, interceptions, intelligence-gathering and the like. Long before 9/11 -- from the Cold War -- we have vested extraordinarily broad surveillance powers in the U.S. Government to the point that we have turned ourselves into a National Security andSurveillance State. Terrorist attacks do not happen because there are too many restrictions on the government's ability to eavesdrop and intercept communications, or because there are too many safeguards and checks. If anything, the opposite is true: the excesses of the Surveillance State -- and the steady abolition of oversights and limits -- have made detection of plots far less likely. Despite that, we have an insatiable appetite -- especially when we're frightened anew -- to vest more and more unrestricted spying and other powers in our Government, which -- like all governments -- is more than happy to accept it.”

Candidate Obama Versus President Obama

President Obama’s now ardent embrace of the same provisions he so eloquently criticized as a candidate - while aggressively opposing any of the reforms he once advocated on behalf of – has come to epitomize a disturbing shift in this country since 9/11.

The eloquent, pro-civil liberties “candidate Obama” branded the Patriot Act "shoddy and dangerous" and pledged to end it in 2003. In 2005, he pledged to filibuster a Bush-sponsored bill that included several of the recently extended provisions, calling them "just plain wrong".

In perhaps his most forceful critique, he stated, "Government has decided to go on a fishing expedition through every personal record or private document -- through library books they've read and phone calls they've made...We don't have to settle for a Patriot Act that sacrifices our liberties or our safety -- we can have one that secures both."

Now, channeling none other than George W. Bush himself, President Obama warns that any delay of the complete and absolute renewal of the Act - or even the addition of a single privacy protection - would endanger American lives.

Thus, what was once viewed as the signature of Bush/Cheney radicalism is now official, bipartisan Washington consensus – serving to codify our country’s continued departure from its commitment to the basic tenets articulated in the Bill of Rights.

Attempted Reforms Ignored, Rejected

Efforts to address the most dangerous and far reaching components of the Patriot Act have been repeatedly offered by Senators and House members alike – to no avail. The reforms sought have been modest in nature, targeted in scope, and critical to reining in government abuse – without weakening national security.

For example, this year, Senator Bernie Sanders offered an amendment - supported by the American Library Association, the ACLU and the National Association of Booksellers - which would have prevented the government from gaining access to Americans' reading records in libraries and bookstores without a traditional search warrant.

Similarly, former Senator Russ Feingold, during a previous Patriot Act extension fight, sought to require the government to specify more clearly the targets of their investigations and their connections to terrorism, keep the FBI from using its authority to engage in broad-based data-mining of Americans’ phone, library and business records, more effective checks on government searches of Americans’ personal records, reform the FISA Amendments Act by repealing the retroactive immunity provision for the same telecom companies that continue to make billions off overcharging the very customers they betrayed, and prevent “bulk collection” of the contents of Americans’ international communications.

Not only have such attempts been rejected year after year, many aren’t even granted a Congressional hearing or vote. Just as disturbing is the failure of the mainstream media to dedicate any significant time and attention to an issue that so clearly warrants a vigorous national debate – such as how to strike the proper balance between civil liberties and national security.

The Bill of Rights Under Siege

Some important questions demand answers: Does increasingly intrusive and even unconstitutional anti-terrorism measures actually make us any safer (or less so)? If so, what is the price we are willing to pay for that additionally security?

Since 9/11 an undeniable pattern has emerged, from illegal search and seizures to warrantless wiretapping to the GPS tracking of cell phones to airport body scanners to the redefinition of Habeas Corpus to the increasing use of rendition for the purposes of torturing prisoners yet to be charged with a crime to military tribunals replacing courts of law, among many others.

What were once considered unassailable civil liberties granted to ALL citizens are under siege. The consequences of such a loss would be profound. Without the fundamental reform of the Patriot Act I fear this loss will be a permanent, and the American experiment will forever be altered.

Moving Forward: Building a Left/Right Coalition

So what to do? From a purely ideological perspective, the potential exists for growing a left/right coalition around a mutual commitment to the Bill of Rights. Already, more than 400 local, county and state resolutions have been passed in opposition to the Patriot Act. But, interest and opposition energy has largely waned over time. This must change.

On the left, while there still remains significant opposition (as evidenced by the recent votes in the House and Senate), a much larger and vocal effort existed when President Bush was abusing the same powers that exist now – no doubt in part due to sharing party affiliation with the new President. We must make the case to these voters that regardless of who sits in the White House, these are powers that NO branch of government, or intelligence agency, deserves.

On the right, it is common place to vocally declare allegiance to the Constitution and the principles of freedom and liberty. Yet, the Patriot Act – which desecrates those very principles – is close to a non-issue, with more focus on the alleged grave threat posed by expanding health care. This group’s inherent distrust of President Obama – warranted or not – may serve to enhance the likelihood of convincing these voters that the Patriot Act represents a clear and present danger to everything they espouse.

Also working in our favor is the broad based, ideologically diverse “Patriot Act Reform” coalition that already exists, including the ACLU (an excellent source of Patriot Act related information), the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the CATO Institute, the Liberty Coalition, the American Library Association, the Bill of Rights Defense Committee, and the Competitive Enterprise Institute. While impressive, this coalition must be vastly expanded.

Irrational fears of terrorism, hyped by political, military and corporate interests, are at the root of our nation's current "civil liberties" crisis. We must counter this growing “fear industrial complex” with a “people’s majority” dedicated to preserving the Bill of Rights and protecting the privacy of American citizens. This challenge - and responsibility - should begin in earnest today.


Zack Kaldveer is the Communications Director of the Consumer Federation of California, a non-profit advocacy organization. CFC campaigns for state and federal laws that place consumer protection ahead of corporate profit. Each year, CFC testifies before the California legislature on dozens of bills that affect millions of our state's consumers. CFC also appears before state agencies in support of consumer regulations. Recent CFC legislative issues include: protecting consumer financial privacy, advocating for single payer health care, supporting public financing of elections, cracking down on predatory mortgage and payday lenders, implementing an extraction tax on Big Oil, prohibiting manufacturers from keeping secret vital safety information about defective products, repealing California's anti-democratic two-thirds budget and tax rule, enacting cell phone users rights, and strengthening food safety laws. Zack also authors the blog Privacy Revolt..

In the War Against the People, The FBI Says Anything Goes

CommonDreams.org

The FBI should not be given more power to spy on dissenters in America. In fact, it should not have that power at all.

Once upon a time, the FBI could investigate a person or organization only when the agency had reasonable suspicion of wrongdoing. This crucial requirement came about after the revelations of massive FBI abuse in the 1960s and early 1970s.

In 1976, Sen. Frank Church of Idaho held hearings on FBI wrongdoing. The Church Committee’s findings shed crucial light.

In the wake of the hearings, the attorney general of the United States drafted guidelines that mandated a criminal predicate before the FBI could launch an investigation. While often honored in the breach, and watered down over the years, until 9/11 this requirement served as a crucial bulwark against FBI intrusion into our protected First Amendment activities.

Unfortunately after the Sept. 11 attacks, first under Attorney General John Ashcroft and then under Attorney General Michael Mukasey, the requirement of a criminal predicate was removed. As a result, the FBI and other anti-terrorist agencies spied on many forms of legitimate protest and dissent. For example, pacifist groups such as the Thomas Merton Center and Catholic Worker were investigated under the rubric of domestic terrorism.

Protests have been a special target. For instance, 15 months prior to the 2008 Republican National Convention in St. Paul, Minn., a specially created FBI Intelligence Center began to spy on, and place informants in, groups it suspected were going to participate in demonstrations.

President Obama campaigned on protecting our civil liberties, so you might have expected his attorney general, Eric Holder, to provide people with greater protections from FBI snoops. But he has not. And it is about to get even worse.

The new Domestic Investigations and Operations Guide will empower the FBI to dispatch surveillance teams, to follow targets, to dig through trash, to search commercial databases and to expand the use of informants to infiltrate a wide range of organizations.

If you are part of a group that disagrees with government policy in Iraq or Afghanistan, or that dislikes nuclear energy, the next time you throw out your trash, an FBI agent may be examining it a few hours later — from what you eat to what you buy to what you read and think.

The next time you attend a meeting to fight for better schools, protest drug testing on animals or criticize almost any aspect of government policy, the person next to you may be an informant, recording everything you say. Or perhaps the informant will participate in the meeting, steering the organization’s activities in ways the government wishes.

It is now almost ten years after 9/11, the event that frightened many into giving the FBI broad spying authority — authority that now threatens the very essence of democracy. Piece by piece, the constitutional protections for dissent are disappearing.

It’s time for new congressional hearings, similar to the Church Committee’s, on FBI spying. We must protest the new expanded powers about to be bestowed on the FBI and follow that with a demand to Attorney General Holder for new guidelines ensuring that dissent and protest will be off-limits to the FBI.

Michael Ratner

Michael Ratner is the president of the Center for Constitutional Rights. He is co-author with Margaret Ratner Kunstler of “Hell No: Your Right to Dissent in the Twenty-First Century”

Margaret Ratner Kunstler

Margaret Ratner Kunstler is former education director at the Center for Constitutional Rights. She is co-author with Michael Ratner of “Hell No: Your Right to Dissent in the Twenty-First Century”